How Top Insurance Teams Handle Bank Reconciliation
Source: Unsplash
All businesses deal with bank reconciliation. It’s one of those behind-the-scenes tasks that can make or break your financial operations.
You spend hours matching records and fixing discrepancies. But others get it done in minutes—and with barely any effort.
They close the books faster and catch issues before they become bigger. They don’t waste time second-guessing their numbers.
The difference isn’t only better software. It’s a clearer process with fewer manual steps. It's leveraging tools to handle a large number of transactions across different systems.
You no longer have to put up with a messy, inconsistent, or slow reconciliation process. Top-performing insurance teams have already figured out a way around it.
And the best part? It's more achievable than you might think.
Let's walk through how bank reconciliation works in insurance. We'll also have a look into what automation can do to make the process faster, easier, and more reliable.
Bank reconciliation is making sure your financial records match what the bank says.
You’re keeping a list of all the money your business receives and spends. The bank also keeps a list of every transaction.
Every now and then, you have to compare your accounting records with the bank statement. You check to see if everything lines up. And if something doesn’t match, you figure out why and fix it.
That’s bank reconciliation. It helps you keep your financial data accurate. It also helps you catch errors before they become bigger issues later on.
Money moves fast in insurance. It can also get complicated fast. Unlike other industries, these businesses often have to juggle:
It's even harder to track when a single payment covers several policies or claims. Your system won't recognize it as a direct one-to-one match. As such, you'd have to split it up and categorize it yourself.
With all these things to consider, the stakes are much higher for insurance teams.
Even a few mismatched records can lead to serious issues when it comes time to audit. There could be compliance issues, strained partner relationships, or worse, lost money.
That’s why it’s vital to get bank reconciliation right. It’s much more than just a box to tick at the end of each month for compliance.
Reconciliation helps your team verify your records. It ensures all transactions are properly accounted for. It’s a core process that keeps your financial data clean and helps prevent fraud.
In a typical reconciliation process, your finance team might:
This will work fine if you're only handling a few transactions or managing a few clients. But as your business expands, manual recon becomes more unsustainable and impractical. It won't be able to keep up, especially with a high volume of transactions.
The manual method doesn’t only drain time. It also adds risk, especially in an industry where precision is critical. Here are the pitfalls of manual bank reconciliation:
Teams can spend hours (or even days) reviewing one account. It takes a lot of time and effort aligning transactions across systems.
Bank recon involves many details to verify and manage. It’s easy to input the wrong amount, miss a duplicate, or post to the wrong account. Without automation, you might record the same transaction twice or miss it entirely.
Reconciliation delays mean you’re often looking at outdated balances. This makes decisions riskier since you’ll either notice issues too late or have to guess your next move.
Records are often scattered across different spreadsheets or platforms. Transactions may also differ in formats, making it harder to match records. As such, tracking adjustments across systems proves to be a tedious process.
Source: Pexels
Forward-thinking insurance teams have found a workaround for this bottleneck. They’re now using automation to stay on top of bank reconciliation.
Instead of matching everything by hand, an automated system does the brunt of the work and flags only the exceptions.
Here’s what bank recon automation looks like:
With an automated tool, you can connect your banking platform to your finance system. No more waiting for the end of each month to download bank statements yourself. No more CSV imports.
Modern systems automatically pull transactions daily or in real time from your bank. This means you’re never behind on reconciliation.
Modern tools sync with your claims platform, policy admin system, or GL. They match each deposit or withdrawal to a corresponding claim, premium, or GL entry.
With automation, data syncs across your core insurance systems in real time. This means you won't have to enter the same information on different platforms. You also won't have to worry about mismatches.
Automation uses smart rules to match entries based on amount, date, and reference IDs.
If a deposit matches a premium invoice within an amount and date range, it is automatically cleared. Or, if a payment applies to several policies or claims, the system will flag it for review.
Automated systems also learn from patterns over time. They can adjust and clear recurring transactions. This means less manual intervention and a more efficient system.
When a match isn’t perfect, automated tools flag the issue. They also assign it to the right person and track the resolution process.
No more digging through spreadsheets. Your finance team only steps in when something doesn’t align. With this, you can resolve issues before they turn into audit flags or reporting delays.
Modern tools make month-end reviews much easier by tracking every action. Audit trails show which records matched and which didn’t. They also show those that were manually resolved.
With time-stamped logs, you know precisely who cleared what and when they cleared it. Notes also show more insight into the hows or whys of an issue.
When you have such extensive data, you can face external audits with confidence and ease.
Let’s be clear: even the best automation tool won’t fix bad or incomplete data. Automated reconciliation only works when your system has the right information to work with.
Here’s what your system needs access to:
Bonus: Managing more than one company or account? Your system should keep separate books for each. It should track which funds are held in trust and which belong to your operating account.
If you want to automate bank reconciliation, you need a tool that simplifies the process. Apart from reducing manual effort and intervention, it should also reduce liability. This is essential for insurance businesses where you’re handling funds for others.
Here are the key features to look for in reconciliation tools:
We’ve been talking about auto reconciliation as a concept, but how does it apply to actual scenarios? Let’s look at the following examples:
A large employer sends a single $50,000 payment to cover premiums for 12 group health plans. But in your bank feed, it shows up as one lump-sum deposit.
Without more detail, it’s hard to know how to divide the payment across accounts. Your team would have to spend hours tracing the funds back to each policy and client.
But with automation, the system reads the employer ID and invoice data. It then splits the payment and applies each amount to the right plan.
Automated tools save you all the hassle. You won't have to dig through spreadsheets yourself to find out what goes where. This means the whole process becomes much smoother and faster to deal with.
Let’s say your system shows a claim was approved for $2,580. But the bank only shows a $2,550 withdrawal. There’s a $30 gap that could be due to a processing fee or provider adjustment.
If unflagged, the mismatch could throw off your reports and return inaccurate data. It could also go unnoticed and cause delays when it’s time to audit.
Automated reconciliation spots the difference right away. It alerts your team so you can confirm the fee and record the change.
This means cleaner finances and more confidence in your numbers. You know exactly where every dollar went and came from, even across platforms or accounts.
Now, suppose a provider submits the same claim twice, and both get paid by mistake.
Two separate entries show up in your GL, and both appear in the bank feed. Matching them by hand, they might look like two valid transactions.
But automation recognizes the duplicate based on claim number, amount, and provider info. It stops the second payment from being cleared and flags it for review.
This helps prevent overpayment and unnecessary recovery work later on.
When you think about automation, you might assume less control over your systems. But that’s not what happens at all. In fact, you get more control over your operations.
Automated logs show who did what and when. Error tracking helps you catch and fix issues right away. Role-based approvals make sure the right people sign off.
All these give you better oversight without slowing things down for your business.
Source: Unsplash
The best insurance teams rely on automation for a reason. They use it to streamline tasks and prepare for audits with ease. It also helps them uncover trends and make confident decisions.
If your bank reconciliation process still relies on manual reviews, you’re missing out. It's about time to make the shift to automated bank reconciliation systems.
With modern tools, your team can save hours of manual work and reconcile more quickly. You can reduce manual errors and risk. You can also track cash in real time and always be prepared for external audits.
These tools also scale with transaction volume and entity count. That means they’re future‑proof as your organization grows.
Curious what automated bank reconciliation could look like for your insurance team?
We work with TPAs, MGAs, and carriers to automate finance workflows. We'll show you how to work smarter without overhauling your existing systems.
Talk to our team to see how you can simplify your workflow and close faster.
